33 Responses to "Aa ri sakhi main tohe preet sikha doon"
Arunji,
Congratulations on reaching your first “melodious century”. 🙂 I must say THANK YOU from bottom of my heart for sharing your knowlege with us. I remember the joy I got when I saw your first post. I think I was the first one to write the comment on your first post. I was very very happy to see our in house encyclopedia, under the list of “post by readers” category. Pehli shatak mein bhale hi195 din lage, lekin ab doosri shatak mein shaayad 159 (or may be less than that) 🙂 Phir se aapka dhanyawaad kehna chaahungi.
LikeLike
Sir, hearty congratulations on your 100 th post !! all your posts and comments have enriched us with hundred folds more than what it actually seems (as very rightly noted by Kamath sir). all your articles have given us great insights into the historical facts of hindi cinema, personal lifes of the stalwarts, and the other important info and reviving and reliving the nostalgia. thanks and congratulations once again !
LikeLike
Avinash ji,
With your appreciation,I can continue doing similar work in future too. Thanks.
LikeLike
Arunji
WOW Its a stupendous Siddhi. 100 posts means at least 1000 delectable trivias. Everybody is aware how difficult it is to scrounge for genuine info. I think this activity itself is responsible for your good health as it is food for thought and exercise for the brain.
It was heartening to note that Atulji is helping you with lyrics writing. Considering how daunting the task is it is really commendable. Great going…
LikeLike
Aha, and congratulations Arun ji,
As others have commented before, your 100 posts are worth much much more, for the amount of hard to find information that you include in them.
Great going, and keenly look forward to many hundreds of more posts from you.
Rgds
Sudhir
LikeLike
Wonderful posts. For some reason we(at least I) seem to be interested in tidbits about the film personalities, their luck and fortunes and their impact. Your posts not only provide these but also seem to group them and put them in a context or a unifying theme. I have enjoyed most of those I read and could understand. Please continue.
LikeLike
Arunji,
Congratulations. It is our privilage and pleasure to go through your posts. In fact each and every post of yours is a learning experience and we eagerly look forward to your valuble comments. We pray to the almighty to give you a long and healthy life and please continue to enlighten and entertain us with many more write-ups.
N Venkataraman
LikeLike
Venkataraman ji,
Thanks for your kind words.
I believe that knowledge increases by sharing it.
-AD
LikeLike
Congratulations both for your 100th post, plus discovering this great fact Arunkumar Sir. But in Achut Kanya (1936), Saraswati Devi Ji had given playback to actress Chandraprabha Ji. Shouldn’t that be the first playback song of Bombay, in Bombay Talkies? Even after that the same combination of playback singer – actress was repeated in Janmabhoomi (1936). This information by you is very rare, but not the first playback song of Bombay. Unfortunately not even the first playback song of Sagar movietone. The first playback opportunity in Sagar was when Rajkumari Banaraswali Ji sang for Sabita Devi Ji in Gram Kanya (1936). But this information that you have shared is anyway very valuable and very praiseworthy. Best wishes to all your future ventures and a happy life ahead. Kudos to your kind and generous and very knowledgeable self.
LikeLike
Vidur ji,
Thanks for your studied comments.
If I am not mistaken the songs of Saraswati Devi for her sister Chandraprabha can not be called ” Playbacks” in the true sense as these were sung while doing the actual shooting of the scene itself.Only thing was instead of the actress,it was someone else singing,but at the time of shooting itself.
Playback will be called when the song is recorded separately and then added to the film shoot,matching with the Lip movement of the actor on the screen.
The first 2 songs do not,according to me,qualify to be called as ‘ Playbacks’.
As far as RK’s songs are concerned,i have not seen the film Village Girl aka gram kanya-1936,nor do I have any info about it. On the face of it,your info seems to be like a Playback.
But a question remains,if it is so,then why is THIS song not described as the FIRST PLAYBACK ?
There could be the following possibilities-
1. Sabita devi always sang her own songs,so in this film she may not have sung any song-even on the screen.
2. Rajkumari’s songs may have been played only in the background,so they can not be Playbacks,in the real sense.
3. The songs may not have featured in the film at all.
All thru these years,only MAHAGEET has been hailed as the First Playback film in Bombay,which even Anil Biswas has confirmed in his interviews. This can not be for no reasons.
In any case,may be this episode needs some intense research to dig out the right answer-which to me,looks extremely difficult.
-AD
LikeLike
Vidur ji,
Here is what our own Dr.Surjit singh ji has to say about Mahageet,in his “my writings” featuring on his site-
” mahaagiit – This was the first time playback singing was introduced in a
film made in Bombay, great master Anil Biswas was the MD ”
-AD
LikeLike
OK Arunkumar Sir, but there is some possibility. Of course you still deserve the credit for the wonderful post and discovery.
LikeLike
1 | Sadanand Kamath
April 11, 2013 at 8:32 am
Dear Arun,
Hearty congratulations for your first ‘official’ century on the blog. I say ‘official’ because for me ( for other readers in this blog too), you may have already reached the figure close to 600 when your informative comments about old films on this blog are taken in to consideration. Those comments, in my view, are in fact mini articles or write-ups.
Please keep them coming in the days to come.
LikeLike
Arunkumar Deshmukh
April 11, 2013 at 6:53 pm
Thanks for your appreciation.
LikeLike