6 Responses to "Na fankaar tujh sa tere baad aayaa"
July 31, 2021 at 2:43 pm
The writer ‘s posts crosses all limits in eugolising a singer beyond limits . Writers post stretch to the limit of irritation and annoyance . Writers post are highly biased and can be easily classified as “Mohammed Rafi ki shaan mein Kaside ”
I don’t know why Atul jee is turning a blind eye to this aspect . However it is his platform , his choice . If he is allowing this beautiful platform as propaganda site for a particular singer we can’t help it . Rafi was a great singer and so we’re so many others including Mohd Aziz . All singers should be respected in the same manner . If Rafi is Rafi Saheb then Laksmikant Saheb , Pyarelal Saheb , Anand Baxi Saheb , Mohammed Aziz saheb, Shabir Kumar Saheb , Abhijeet Saheb , Kumar Shanu Saheb on & on & on
LikeLike
July 31, 2021 at 6:10 pm
Avinash Kumar ji,
I have read your opinion about the post, but I will not object to anything that you wrote, because it is your opinion and it is not binding on other readers at all. It only reveals your thinking process. So be it.
In this Blog there is total freedom to the contributors to express their opinions, as long as it does not cross the limits of tolerance or does not express unacceptable comments about others.
Mrs. Nahm ji is one of our respected contributors and is with the Blog for more than 10 years. We have never found her making unacceptable claims about any artiste. Leave aside writing ill about others.
Tolerance about others’ opinion is becoming slowly a vanishing quality, but when in a public domain certain decency is expected.
Thanks for visiting the Blog.
-AD
August 1, 2021 at 5:30 pm
Dear Arun jee
I have been a regular visitor to this site for more than a decade . You may verify this at your end . And I have always appreciated the efforts put in by Atul jee and enthusiast like you in compiling this wonderful blog . Thanks for replying to my post/opinion . It is a good thing that Atul jee and You have given full freedom to contributors . A lot of respect for that . Arun jee don’t you think it is going overboard mis using that freedom by giving respect to one artist and not to others ? Sir just think if , some one to write a post and mentions you as Arun Sahab and me as Avinash or vice a versa . If you mean to say that to accept “bias” is tolerance , yes there may be certain intolerant people by that definition .
I would request you to think over it there is no harm in giving respect to artists. Then give to every artist . Please don’t discriminate . My culture my education has taught me respect each and everybody without any discrimination . For me it is Atul jee ,Arun jee , Nahm jee , Avinash jee (scrapwala) Parveen Jee And Not Atul , Arun , Nahm Jee , Praveen Jee .
I hope I haven able to clarify my unbiased and undiscriminating opinion. If not , thanks for bearing with “intolerant ” opinion
In any case I am an ardent follower of the wonderful blog . I wish this discrimination is eliminated in future posts dept is upto You .
Thanks with regards and best wishes, as always . If you wish you can communicate on my email id
LikeLike
August 2, 2021 at 7:13 am
AVINASH KUMAR ji,
Whatever I wanted to express, I have already done so in my first reply and I do not wish to add anything further to it, because it was quite expressive.
I like to keep my opinions and views about others to myself. I feel one should not try to force them on others, because others too have their opinions, even if they prefer not to express.
Praising one does not lower the image of the other automatically.
-AD
LikeLike
Atul’s Song A Day- A choice collection of Hindi Film & Non-Film Songs 
July 31, 2021 at 10:28 am
Nahm Ji,
Thanks for an excellent post. I would not comment on any line of yours because every line is a touching tribute to the great Mohammad Rafi. ( ‘Mausiqui ka Paigambar’ to quote Naushad Saheb)
I have neither seen ‘Kroadh ‘ nor heard this song. Truly a song to cherish
LikeLike
July 31, 2021 at 10:56 am
This is one song that I have heard a number of times. And I may have used it in a few of my posts on Rafisaa-. “The eternal smile-spreader”
LikeLike